SOUTH SALT LAKE CITY — John Steinbeck’s East of Eden is a sprawling family saga inspired by the biblical story of Cain and Abel. Now, director David Morgan has brought it to the stage at Parker Theatre’s Studio Black Box in South Salt Lake City. And somehow, he’s managed to squeeze more than 600 pages of family drama into roughly two hours. There is a lot to unpack!
I read the novel before attending opening night, although I wouldn’t say homework is required to enjoy the production. A little familiarity certainly helps, particularly when the story moves between generations. We begin with brothers Adam and Charles Trask before shifting to Adam’s twin sons, Caleb and Aaron. Each has a complicated relationship with his family, and a particularly unpleasant woman named Cathy makes everything considerably worse.
Much of the novel’s backstory is condensed into vignette-style flashbacks and narration, sometimes using Steinbeck’s own words. We meet Adam and Charles as adults, and by the final third of Act One, the younger generation is already taking center stage. It’s a brisk approach, but Morgan keeps the focus on the relationships and the question that matters most: are we destined to repeat our parents’ mistakes, or can we choose differently?
The Studio Black Box is wonderfully intimate. From the front row, actors occasionally pass right beside you during exits and scene changes. The set, designed by Marguerite Morgan, is simple: a bed frame, a door frame, wooden tables, and mismatched chairs, rearranged to create different spaces. Combined with the wooden flooring, everything has a rustic, lived-in quality that suits the late-19th-century California setting without cluttering the small stage.
What impressed me most about the staging was how little the production needed to suggest a change of place or time. With the audience so close, there’s nowhere for a performer to hide, and elaborate scenery would have been more distracting than helpful. Instead, a shifted chair or an arrangement of the furniture is often enough. That simplicity also makes the intense moments feel uncomfortably immediate. When an argument escalates, you’re not watching it unfold from some distance across an auditorium. You’re practically sitting in the middle of the Trask family’s problems, whether you like it or not.
Kristian Huff’s original score is another highlight. Built largely around strings and piano, it has an old Western quality that fits beautifully. Some passages are almost comforting, while flashbacks and scenes involving Cathy introduce a piercing violin melody that reminded me a little of Dracula. It’s deeply unsettling, which is exactly what those moments need.
Marguerite Morgan’s sound effects are equally impressive. Some are prerecorded, while others are created practically by actors offstage. A disturbing flashback involving Cathy’s father includes the sharp sound of a whipping, and several confrontations depend on cues landing at precisely the right moment. A mistimed effect could easily make something dramatic unintentionally hilarious. Thankfully, the actors and sound cues never miss a beat.
A large consideration in the script is the intense level of wickedness that the character of Cathy possesses. Somehow, Parker Theatre has found three actresses who make her equally terrible at different stages of her life. Ondine Garner plays young Cathy in flashbacks, Alexis Ross portrays her as an adult married to Adam, and Annadee Morgan takes over when Caleb and Aaron are older. Each actress brings something different to the role, yet Cathy remains instantly recognizable.
Garner is particularly unnerving. Her Cathy seems almost dead inside, though the performance is anything but monotonous. When she’s cruel, there’s a strange, playful lilt in her voice, as if she’s taunting people simply to see what happens. She often stands perfectly still at center stage, barely reacting to the chaos around her. Somehow, that stillness is more frightening than any outburst could be.
Ross gives Cathy a convincing facade of vulnerability. When she meets Adam, she’s warm and gentle enough that you can understand why he trusts her. Around other people, however, that warmth vanishes. Ross communicates an enormous amount through her eyes, even when her expression barely changes. Her upright posture and matter-of-fact delivery make Cathy’s contempt especially chilling. She doesn’t seem to consider anyone else’s feelings worth acknowledging.
Morgan’s older Cathy has acquired wealth, power, and the confidence of someone who considers herself untouchable. Her cruelty is more openly amused, recalling the girlish taunting of Garner’s performance. The resemblance between Ross and Morgan is uncanny, but it’s the shared mannerisms and controlled delivery that really make the transitions work. Cathy actually appears less frequently than you might expect. Still, even when she’s nowhere in sight, her influence hangs over nearly everything.
Thankfully, East of Eden isn’t two straight hours of misery. Jordan Vance as Lee and Dylan Wright as Samuel Hamilton provide some much-needed levity. Lee, Adam’s Chinese servant, initially speaks in stereotypical pidgin English because it’s what others expect of him. Vance gives him warmth, intelligence, and a wonderfully dry awareness of the family’s absurd behavior. His scenes with the twins are especially lovely. Lee is frequently the voice of reason in a household where reason is, frankly, in short supply.
Wright’s Samuel is similarly kindhearted, with an easy, playful humor. The comedy between Samuel and Lee feels observational rather than forced; they simply notice how ridiculous everyone else is being. Wright also handles the passage of time convincingly. Rather than switching performers, he adopts a scratchier voice and subtle limp as Samuel ages.
The evening’s standout performance belongs to Kristian Huff as Caleb Trask. Given the Cain and Abel parallels, I expected Caleb to arrive as the obviously violent brother. Instead, Huff introduces a surprisingly sweet, affectionate young man. Caleb is stronger and more assertive than Aaron, but their roughhousing is playful. Huff also moves naturally between narration and dialogue, never making those transitions feel awkward.
Most importantly, he refuses to turn Caleb into a straightforward villain. Caleb worries he’s inherited his mother’s cruelty, yet we see how tender he can be with Aaron and their friend Abra, also played by Garner. More than anything, he wants his father’s approval. In one especially touching scene, Caleb prepares to give Adam a present. Huff practically glows, nervously fiddling with the gift bag and anticipating his father’s reaction. I could see the twinkle in his eyes from my seat. For a moment, he’s simply a boy hoping to make his dad proud. Even when Caleb makes terrible choices, Huff gives us someone to root for.
Costume designer Dvorah Governale also deserves recognition. Period productions can sometimes bury everyone in endless brown, gray, and beige, but these costumes incorporate reds, blues, and greens alongside the expected earthy tones. Against the wooden set, those colors distinguish characters without feeling out of place. I particularly loved Lee’s patterned red Tangzhuang.
Cathy’s wardrobe changes with her circumstances, too. Her earlier clothing is comparatively muted, while Morgan’s wealthy older Cathy wears gorgeous, luxurious fabrics. A Christmas-green velvet dress and a red-and-gold satin ensemble with white lace and brocade are particularly striking. The richer colors and textures communicate her growing power before she even speaks.
I couldn’t find a fight choreographer credited in the program, but whoever staged the confrontations did an excellent job. Clever angles and spacing make the slaps, punches, and even bites look painfully real. Every swing, grunt, gasp, flinch, and fall is fully committed. I winced more than once, despite knowing perfectly well that nobody was actually getting beaten up in front of me!
At the heart of the production is timshel, which Lee calls “the most important word in the world.” Translated in the story as “thou mayest,” it suggests that people have the choice to overcome evil rather than being condemned to repeat it. Caleb’s fear that he’s inherited Cathy’s cruelty gives that idea real emotional weight. The production doesn’t pretend his mistakes are harmless, but it does leave room for him to become better. That’s a surprisingly hopeful message beneath all the heartbreak.
Fans of the novel should expect some of its more scandalous material to be toned down or omitted. I was curious how certain passages would translate to the stage, and for the most part, they simply don’t. Given the runtime, I understand the decision. Morgan prioritizes the Trask relationships and Caleb’s journey, giving the evening a clear emotional through line. Personally, I didn’t mind most of the changes, although devoted readers may miss particular characters and scenes.
There’s no official rating listed on Parker Theatre’s website, but I’d consider this production PG-13 for its violence and mature themes. Adults will probably get more out of its questions about guilt, responsibility, and forgiveness than younger teenagers.
With its intimate staging, excellent technical work, and strong ensemble, East of Eden is a thoughtful, moving production. It’s certainly not the cheeriest family outing, but it’s far from hopeless. I highly recommend seeing it at Parker Theatre. You’ll have plenty to think about on the drive home.
MORE INFO: East of Eden plays November 13–21 at Parker Theatre’s Studio Black Box, located at 3605 South State Street, South Salt Lake, UT 84115. Performances are at 7:30 p.m. on Fridays and Saturdays, with 3:30 p.m. Saturday matinees. Tickets are $20 and can be purchased online at parkertheatre.org or in person at the box office.
FOLLOW US ON FACEBOOK, INSTAGRAM, and TIKTOK!
If you’re a director, producer or marketing contact who would like to have us review your show, please fill out this form.
If you have comments about this article, please fill out this form.

