SANDY — On Wednesday November 18, I saw Anastasia: The New Broadway Musical produced by the Hale Centre Theatre on the Young Living Centre Stage with direction by Dave Tinney. Anastasia is a personal favorite for me, so I went in with high expectations. The Hale managed to exceed them in every way. Graceful dance numbers, majestic sets, and a leading lady with the voice of an angel made Anastasia the most delightful show I’ve seen all year.

Editor’s Note: Production Photos have not yet been received by UTAJ. When they are, they will be added to this review. Photos can be provided through this form.

With a book by Terrance McNally and music and lyrics by Stephen Flaherty and Lynn Ahrens respectively, Anastasia presents a historically grounded story of the last remaining daughter of a fallen dynasty, the duchess Anastasia. All the world knows the rumors about the girl who may have survived the violent revolution, and two con men, Dmitry and Vlad, plan to present a fake Anastasia to the Dowager Empress in Paris in hopes of claiming a reward. Anya, a girl who has forgotten her past, agrees to join them and become their lost duchess. As the group travels to Paris, Anya and Dmitry grow closer to each other, while Anya’s clouded past begins to become clearer. Anya realizes she truly is the duchess Anastasia and must choose between the past she has always wanted and a future with the new friends she has found.

Makenna Ashby plays the leading role of Anya with a sweet, strong personality. Ashby managed the lines perfectly, using great inflection and body language to convey meaning. She was playful in her movements, yet graceful in her dancing. Ashby shone as a vocalist, with a singing voice that felt like caramel; rich, full, and sweet. Her songs carried the audience away to dreams of a December long ago. Ashby shared a mischievous, lighthearted chemistry with Matthew Oster, who plays Dmitry. The pair worked well together, balancing each other’s movements and sharing subtle touches and glances building Anya and Dmitry’s romance. Oster had a nice voice, with an honest earthy quality to it. However, there were moments when Oster seemed to struggle with the higher notes, especially at the climax of “My Petersburg.”

Scenic designer Nate Bertone earns the highest of praise for his awe inspiring creations. The sheer number of set pieces crafted for this performance was incredible, and even more impressive was how each piece was immaculately detailed matching real world inspiration. It is difficult picking a favorite piece, but the Pont Alexandre bridge is an absolute show stopper. Colossal in scale, the bridge gave the actors space to dance while also containing gorgeous streetlights flickering in time to the music. Another set piece is a massive recreation of the iconic music box serving as a soft bed for the young Anastasia at the beginning of the show. Later, a full sized train car is lowered during the main group’s escape from Russia, while a staggering vintage chandelier graced the opera house. However, the set piece of the life-sized train took a while to lower onto the stage, which interrupted the song “Stay I Pray You.” Finally, a closer look clearly shows even the smaller pieces are crafted by Bertone with ingenuity and care, from the suitcases doubling as trash fires in cold Russia to the red velvet front on the bar during “Land of Yesterday.”

Ethan Kelso plays Gleb, a dedicated officer in the Bolshevik army, determined to track down this false Anastasia. Kelso was precise in his movements, showing military control to all he did. Kelso’s voice was deep and manly, showing a more serious side that gave weight to the entire show.

Tyler Hanson as Vlad Popov and Korianne Orton Johnson as Countess Lily are alluring and winsome to watch in their duet “The Countess and the Common Man.” The way they flowed around one another, then stumbled and needed to take a seat due to their character’s age was adorable. Their humorous attempted lifts and twirls brought the satisfaction of watching an older couple whose love is evident despite the time gone by. Ending it with a double foot-pop as they kissed was a crowning jewel to the scene.

Choreographer Afton Wilson created a series of beautiful dances for the show. The scenes set in the old regime featured beautiful slower twirls, presented arms, and more classical moves. These contrasted nicely with the faster songs which featured more modern dancing. The best dance was “Paris Holds the Key (To Your Heart)” which had the dancers whirling around, creating big, fun expressive movements, and running up and down the massive recreation of the Pont Alexandre bridge. It was the lively sort of dance that embodies the spirit of musical theater. The condensed version of Swan Lake during “Quartet at the Ballet” was another high point, with the dancers showing finesse during their lifts and twirls.

Director Dave Tinney did an excellent job of blocking the show to create interesting perspectives and dichotomies. There were many moments when characters used the raised platforms on either side of the stage, or when the stage itself raised and lowered segments to create different dynamics such as the royal family slowly rotating around Anastasia as she slept, or at the end of the show when the dead royal family danced as ghosts just beneath Pont Alexandre bridge. Another great moment was when the Czar and his wife were lifted up on wires during “Once Upon a December (Reprise),” moving beyond poor Anastasia’s reach, to complete a ghostly dance in the air.

Costume designer Joy Zhu (assisted by Emma Ashton) crafted an equally impressive number of unique looks for the show. The ensemble featured muted reds with rough fabrics while in old Russia, which showed texture and layers. These contrasted nicely with the creamy white costumes of the royalty, which featured halo shaped headgear, hanging sleeves, and sparkling diamonds. The costumes in “Paris Holds the Key (To Your Heart)” were brightly colored spring tones, with light flowy fabrics. Not only were the costumes historically accurate and detailed, they clearly had symbolic ties to the story itself, with Anastasia wearing similar shades of blue as the Dowager Empress when they meet at the opera. The color white comes up again when Anastasia accepts herself as the grand duchess and creates a common thread among all the royal characters. Even Vlad and Lily are featured in matching shades of maroon as they rekindle their romance.

Lastly, the lighting design by Jaron Kent Hermansen was wonderful. There was a lovely effect of the lights flashing to imitate a photo taken of the posing royalty on stage. The lights changed color with the mood and intensity of the moment, such as the hazy orange and red shimmering during “Land of Yesterday” or the bright, warm glow during “Paris Holds the Key (To Your Heart)”. Other effects included searchlights, dramatic blackouts, and spotlights on the main characters. The lighting also utilized a variety of extra light sources, such as trash can fires, ornate streetlights, large photo bulbs, chandeliers, and more.

There are plenty more delightful moments worth documenting, yet only attending the show would truly do them justice. Anastasia: The New Broadway Musical at the Hale Centre Theatre was a production worthy of a grand duchess. From the historically inspired costumes and the detailed lighting to the chemistry shared by Ashby and Oster, this may be the best version of Anastasia I’ve ever seen. I would recommend this show to anyone with a love of good theater and encourage all to take a journey into the past with Anastasia.


MORE INFO: ANASTASIA: THE NEW BROADWAY MUSICAL is currently playing at Hale Centre Theatre (9900 South Monroe Street, Sandy, UT 84070) on the Young Living Centre Stage. Performances are held at 7:30 PM on select evenings, with some 12:30 PM and 4:00 PM matinees through January 18, 2027. Note that the cast alternates, with one set of performers on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays, and another set for Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Saturdays. If you wish to see a specific performer, double check their performance days. Tickets typically range from $39 to $91. For the most up-to-date schedule, performance details, and official ticketing, visit the Hale Center Theatre website: www.hct.org

FOLLOW US ON FACEBOOK, INSTAGRAM, and TIKTOK!

If you’re a director, producer or marketing contact who would like to have us review your show, please fill out this form. 

If you have comments about this article, please fill out this form. 

These reviews are made possible by a grant from the Salt Lake County Zoo, Arts, and Parks program.
Avatar photo

ByEllie Smith

Ellie Smith is from Boise, Idaho, (that's BOY-see, not boy-ZEE) and graduated from BYU with a BA in English and a minor in editing and publishing. She performed in plays and musicals throughout high school and college, and she loves belting out show tunes and catching the latest live performance. She believes theater has the power to teach us important lessons about each other and ourselves.